Wednesday, 18 September 2024

Discussing Race and the Global North in 2024

 By Takura Zhangazha*

So in the American (USA) presidential campaign that is underway in 2024, there have been multiple racist overtones from the Republican candidate, Donald Trump and his vice president nominee, JD Vance.  They have both ridiculously argued that Haitian immigrants are stealing cats and dogs to eat in a town called Springfield, Ohio.

The local mayor has dismissed these claims as unfounded and therefore false.  But the Republican campaign team has continued with the narrative as the USA presidential campaign has continued. 

In the United Kingdom, even after the Labour party’s recent electoral victory there were also  anti-immigrant riots in Rotherham which peaked with an attempt to ransack an asylum seekers hotel in the same city. 

In other European countries elections and other political processes have seen the rise of immigration and of course race as big electoral issues.  Not necessarily against Ukrainians but with implied and alleged bias against immigrants of colour.  Especially where it concerns the illegal immigration across the English/French channel and also the awkward Rwanda repatriation plan for asylum seekers. 

What is however apparent as a result of this is that a lot of Western European and North American societies are fixated on immigration, race and racist narratives of where their societies are at.

Even as they seek to recruit people from Africa, Asia and South America to come and undertake social care and health work in their societies. 

In this, the striking irony is the politicized nature of these global north societies and their perceptions of immigrants, voting and prioritization of the protection of Israel in the ongoing genocide in Palestine.  

And also newfound censorships of social media accounts that are deemed to be not in line with their various governments key foreign and domestic policy positions. (A very popular platform AfricanStream has been banned from Youtube, Facebook and Instagram) 

As an African living in Africa, these issues should be relatively distant from my own consciousness.  But because we are all invariably connected to the great African Diaspora in the global north, we still have to debate these developments as objectively as we possibly can. 

And a key starting point is to acknowledge that the Global North countries or the Western world as it has been historically referred to by mainstream media is in what I would consider a societal populist crisis about race relations and racism in its presentations of its democratic and social set up.   The colonial style cultural othering of black and brown faces is back in full political and electoral vogue in Western, Eastern Europe and also in North America. 

And as Africans we need to contend with this reality whether we are living there or not.  Or at least advise those that are close to us and sending their remittances back home that we are aware of their increasingly difficult positioning in societies that have prominent politicians either accusing them of eating cats and dogs.  Or deliberately taking jobs that their own ordinary people will not do or are under qualified for. 

This goes beyond popular movements such as the Black Lives Matter.  This is quite literally a  cultural and historical phenomenon of identity based nationalism that has multiple conspiracy theories.  From arguing that mass migration leads to changes in which race(s) take control of their societies via electoral numbers crunch games through to questioning the authenticity of black or brown peoples’ birth places and right to pursue political leadership. 

What is more insidious is the evident subtlety of the racism as presented by mainstream and social media platforms.  Almost as though this were completely acceptable public interest language and debates.

But hegemony is what it chooses itself to be in its historicity.  Yes, racial discrimination was long ended by the United Nations and concerted struggles of humanity across colour lines but it now has new populist versions that are sanitized by a gullible mainstream media, social media corporations, billionaires and exceedingly self-absorbed, narcissistic political leaders.  With the latter pandering to the reflectively worst forms of xenophobia, racism, gatekeeping and ahistorical assumptions of radical nationalism. 

The point however as an African is not to get angry at these new but relatively old historical developments.   Instead it is better to seek to understand and debate them in not only their racial but also economic and mimicry terms. 

With the full knowledge that because of ‘mimicry’ and material desire, a lot of our young African comrades will still continue taking both legal but often times illegal perilous journeys to the global north.  

Now there are many progressive comrades in the global north who are aware of these developments.  And they are trying their best to mitigate the racism and fighting the corner for racial equality and justice.   Some of them are even policy makers.  But recent electoral results show their influence to be waning and they with almost apologetic regret acknowledge this. 

Then there are also the African brothers and sisters who tragically are also part of the racist narrative either telling their black or brown colleagues to sort their papers and go home.  Or how newer immigrants do not deserve to be in the global north unlike them who have already started families or have been there long duree and acquired either green-cards or citizenship.  All of which does not change the fact of racism and its multiple end effects where they are living. 

But as a final point, it is evident that the Global North, while being arguably democratic, has re-emergent serious issues with race, immigration and racism. At a populist and electoral level that should make every black or brown person pause and reflect on what is going on there.  Or ask questions about how this is increasingly affecting global politics and international relations.

And for sure, just like they comment on our democratic credentials in the Global South, we can most certainly comment on their flailing ones in the Global North.

*Takura Zhangazha writes here in his personal capacity (takura-zhangazha.blogspot.com) 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment