In
reply to ‘ You lazy (Intellectual) African Scum’
By
Takura Zhangazha.
A number of friends recently forwarded
a link to a popular blogsite titled ‘You Lazy (Intellectual) African Scum!’ to my email inbox. It's written
by a Zambian doctoral student based in the United States of America, a Mr.
Field Ruwe. It has an anecdotal beginning wherein it offers a real or imagined
scenario about an assumedly black African sitting next to a white American on
an aeroplane ride from Los Angeles to Boston.
It turns out that the white American has worked extensivley in Africa
and spent a lot of time in Zambia(he even knows the nickname of Zambian
President Sata!)
What follows as one reads
further is what I would hazard to call ‘bar-stool’ conversation. The white
expatriate who is referred to as Walter, explains much to the initial shock and
then eventually ‘deification’ acceptance of his one person African audience
everything that is assumedly wrong with African society, intellectuals and
African political leaders.
On the face of it,
the observations made by 'Walter' are premised on assumptions of ‘hard facts’ or
alternatively a ‘let’s cut the white/black man nonsense’ and look at facts. The
underlying truth however is that 'Walter’s' arguments are made on the very same
basis, i.e a white man lecturing an assumed ahistorical black figure on the
comparative historical successes of ‘western civilization’.
All this done with
the seeminlgy neat caveat that it is completely the fault of the Africans that
they are where they are today.
And to make 'Walter’s' argument
seemingly insurmountable and beyond reproach, he invokes the now ubiquitous
comparison of what the Japanese, Chinese and Indians have done to play ‘catch-up’
with the Western world. Never mind the fact that the historical trajectories of
these three countries have been profoundly different from those of
Africa.
In any event it is an argument
that dismisses Africa’s historical arrival at where it is in favour of
substituting the making of African history for a Western trajectory. So much so
to the extent that it would not be surprising had Mr. Ruwe’s ‘Walter’ character
insisted that Africa first undergo not only an industrial/ technological revolution a-la-carte the West but ensure that
the same is 'teleologically' accompanied by a couple of World Wars (with the
attendant horrific genocides) as well as never ending ‘war’s on terror’ against one ‘bloc’ or the
other from the global east.
Knowing my colleagues as I do,
they probably forwarded the link to me because while they might find some of the blog’s contents unpalatable, they are probably drawn to what they think are some valid points. Particualry if the
argument entails moving away from the syndrome of blaming the ‘Western other’ in dealing with the challenges that Africa and
Africans are facing continentally and globally.
In fact, Mr. Ruwe’s friend goes into a semi-confessional mode
where after the ‘real or imagined’ berating and denigrative lecture from ‘Walter’,
he undertakes a serious self whipping act of contrition.
After which, he then
offers advice to Zambian President Mr. Sata not to be ‘highly strung’ by ‘Walter’.
This contrition however has a ‘technological’
catch to it wherein Mr. Ruwe argues “Knowing
well that King Cobra will not embody innovation at Walter’s level let’s begin
to look for a technologically active-positive leader who can succeed him after
a term or two. That way we can make our own stone crushers, water filters,
water pumps, razor blades, and harvesters. Let’s dream big and make tractors,
cars, and planes, or, like Walter said, forever remain inferior.” And therein lies the fundamental problem with
the argumentation.
Its premise is too embedded in
a wrong assumption that Africans are ‘inferior’
because they do not make tractors, cars, planes and razor blades even (in fact
we do make cars or contribute significantly to the making of them, even though
we might not have been the first to invent them).
We might not be as technologically savvy as
our Western compatriots but we are not here to be judged inferior as human
beings by them on the same basis either. If that is the case, we might as well all manufacture nuclear weapons.
Our challenges may be more numerous but in some instances are not any more different than those of our compatriots in the West. That they hide their societal challenges from full
purview does not mean the same challenges are in any less need of redress.
Contrary to the assertions of ‘Walter’,
we are all equal as human beings. Wholesale judgements of the success or failure
of a continent have rarely been made elsewhere save with regard to the ‘native’ African and the African continent. To seek to perpetuate such judgements is borderline acquiescence to racist
stereotypes of our continent. It can only be viewed as an unfortunate attempt at the ‘prejudicial truth'.
Hi Takura... Firstly I must say it was an interesting article and quite captivating! It reminded me of a book called 'Capitalist Nigger' wriiten by Chika Onyeani. Awesome book, admittedly! Anyways, in my opinion, that article was not to dis-credit Black people as such, though there were hints of it. I think the real message in the article was for us Black people to start being entrepreneurs! And yes, we Africans do have the capability to make cars & many other things, but somehow we have not yet done it! The problem with Africa is POLITICS and power hungry people! The problem lies with its leaders & their gullible nature to the Western world!
ReplyDeleteThanks Kuthula and Thatoyame. I apologise for the late response on this one. What intrigued me when I saw responses to this same article after it had been posted elsewhere was the serious 'despising of self' that is sometimes glaringly evident among comrades. They try as much as is possible to sound enlightened or to demonstrate knowledge based on their proximity to Western epistemology and do not realize that in the same process, they are de-humanising (as it were) their own sense of origin, identity and perhaps most sadly of all, their own continental history...
ReplyDeleteMr. Takura Zhangazha, i believe your assertions are widely hollow and miss the fundamental faculty behind Mr. Ruwe's article.
ReplyDeleteYeah yeah yeah blah blah blah... is it beside the truth that our continent is a "failure"? that our leaders plunder wealth at the expense of the poverty stricken populace? don't you reckon it is high time we found ingrown solutions to our problems and rid ourselves of our panhandling love affair with the West? we have the resources, now we've got the education, what we need is a total overhaul of the orientation that drives our very existence as humans....not as black people, nor as Africans, nor as descendants of an enslaved race....but as plain simple goal achieving humans, albeit sensible life sustaining goals. until then, my brother; yes we are inferior!